William Pietri

@williampietri@sfba.social

If you see somebody described as "he's just like that" or "he can't help himself", ask if he's like that when he might be held accountable. E.g., in front of his boss, his mom, at church, when a video camera is recording.

Occasionally, he really can't help himself. But it usually turns out that he can, and that there's a pattern to when he can't. E.g., he's a jerk to juniors and peer women, but perfectly controlled in front of his male boss. That's when you know it's not illness, it's abuse.

September 23, 2023 at 2:41:15 PM

Yes, thank you! And even if he is "just like that" all the time, that doesn't mean anyone should have to put themselves through being around/associated with him, if they can avoid it.

If he truly "can't help himself", then he should be removed from society for the safety of others.

and seriously, if he can’t help himself does he need some sort of mental health treatment? If he literally can’t control himself someone needs to get him some help.

To play the jerk's advocate, wouldn't it be feasible that there's a medical condition that makes one jerk by default, but lets him crank the niceness level up at the cost of spoons, and he doesn't got spoons for the whole day?

That's not a medical condition, that's the human condition. We all have finite capacity. We all get frustrated when it runs low. But there are patterns to what people do when that happens.

I'm not arguing for the search of such a condition. It probably doesn't exist. My point is, the structure of your argument might be a wee bit problematic, because it rhymes with popular if ill-advised justifications of oppressing people with well-known, well-documented medical problems. Such as people who can sometimes, for a little while, raise up from their wheelchairs and take a couple of steps.

The endpoint of your argument I agree with, but I'd prefer to get there without lending support and credence to the Patriarchy's notions of "non-standard people" on the way.

@riley @williampietri Yeah. It's not "the Human Condition," it's a matter of neurotype, that's the Allistic Human Condition.
.
It's the model their whole world is built on, and the thing Sapolsky described about stress, when you have to take it from above, you survive it by passing it on down.
.
It's not universal enough to be the entire Human Condition - but it's not rare enough to be an "illness."
So, neurotype.

Elk Logo

Welcome to Elk!

Elk is a nimble Mastodon web client. You can login to your Mastodon account and use it to interact with the fediverse.

Expect some bugs and missing features here and there. Elk is Open Source and we're actively improving it as a community project. Join us and let's build it together!

If you'd like to report a bug, help us testing, give feedback, or contribute, reach out to us on GitHub and get involved.

To boost development, you can sponsor the Team through GitHub Sponsors. We hope you enjoy Elk!

TAKAHASHI ShuujiDaniel RoeAnthony FuPatak三咲智子 Kevin DengJoaquín Sánchez

The Elk Team